Well eventually came sooner than later. After turning out 5 goblets in the past couple weeks I figured may as well do this one while I'm on my goblet game. They will get to my cousin for her wedding in the fall.
The new one is the slightly darker one. Mineral oil and then buffed on the outside with white diamond and carnuaba wax. The new one has shellac on the inside. 7 1/4 tall by a smidge over 2 1/2 wide.
Comments and critique always welcome!