I would have just gone to store, but now I will certainly go to the dairy.
ooor and hear me out here because this might initially seem crazy. But you could get some heavy cream from them and make some butter saving the buttermilk.
First off I know the response is "Ryan.. you're crazy.." and sure I get that a lot... but there are some fun reasons to make your own butter.
First up it can taste better, did you know that you can make butter have EVEN MORE butter flavor by culturing it? True, the bacteria produce diacetyl which has an intense buttery flavor (notable off flavor in beer, derided as artificial in movie theater popcorn, but with a wee bit introduced in butter.. delicious). The slightly tangy note is also excellent.
Second it's not actually that hard, especially with a stand mixer.
Third.. ok I don't have a real third reason other than "why not, it's fun
)
This is a pretty decent guide here:
Make delicious and tangy cultured butter with the pros at Cultures For Health. This fermented, cultured butter recipe will create a probiotic rich butter that's a perfect complement for our sourdough and a dozen other uses. Learn how to make cultured butter with Cultures For Health.
culturesforhealth.com
The key is that the culture MUST be mesophilic, that is works at low temperatures. They suggest mesophilic yogurt, but we've had great luck with "active culture sour cream" as a source culture because basically *all* sour cream is cultured with mesophilic bacteria whereas most yogurt is thermophilic (likes heat). The tablespoon/cup is about right.
Inline simplified recipe:
- 2C heavy cream
- 2tbsp active culture sour cream
Warm to room temperature (70-75F), add a bit of cream to the sour cream in stages until it's a thinner slurry then combine, leave at 70-75F for 12-24hrs.
Mix vigorously just below the speed where it splashes in a stand mixer or by hand.
Press out all of the buttermilk, knead on a board to really try to get all of it out. Put in a bowl of cool/cold water and knead it some more to really really get the final residue out. Smear out on a board and add salt to taste and lightly knead to integrate.
You can also use the same "culture" to make cultured buttermilk from whole or 2% milk (same process, just use milk instead of cream) which imho works even better than butter buttermilk because it has more butterfat still in it.. and you know what we say about butter fat!! Yum!