Chicken Soup with Matzoh Balls Recipe

A couple of people asked me recently to post my best Matzoh Ball Soup recipe, so I'm putting it here in case anyone else is interested.

This recipe, BTW, is not Kosher, but rather "Jewish-style" cooking.

Chicken Soup with Matzoh Balls

1) Fill a 6-8 quart casserole about half with water.

2) Add 2 double chicken breasts, boneless and skinless (that's 4 single breasts).

3) Add about 2 C. of chopped carrots (washed and peeled).

4) Add 1 big sweet onion or 2 smaller sweet onions or any 2 good looking onions if the sweet ones are not in season. Quarter the onion(s).

5) Add about 3 big celery stalks chopped in little pieces.

6) Add the soup package *only* from a box of MANISCHEWITZ Matzo Ball & Soup Mix. Set aside the 2nd package in the box. If you're not sure which is which, then open them. The soup mix smells like soup. The other package just looks like corn meal. More on that below.

7) Add maybe 2 cloves of garlic, smashed and peeled. (I just lay my knife blade on it sideways and come down on it once with my fist.)

8) Add about a tsp of pepper. Don't add any salt yet.

9) Optional: If you like your soup thick, then add about 1/2 - 1 C of any long cooking rice.

The water line should be about 2-3" from the top of the pot. If it's not, then add more water. This is where things are approximate. You want the water to cover everything you put in the pot, but you don't want the water to be several inches above everything. You have to be the judge.

Bring it to a boil and then turn the fire down and simmer it uncovered with a gentle boil for about 2 hours. Add more water if it boils way down. Stir it occasionally.

After 2 hours, take out the chicken and chop it up in cubes. Discard any cartilage or nasty bits, and cube the rest. Put it back in the pot.

Now is the time to add salt. The soup mix has some salt in it, so you should taste the soup first and then add salt to taste. You'll need to add a little, but not a lot. You can add more pepper now if you like. I usually add some hot sauce too, maybe a tsp. It's up to you.

Follow the directions on the Manischewitz package to make the matzoh ball dough with the 2nd package in the box. You mix up the dough, and let it rest it the fridge for about half an hour, then make the matzoh balls, drop them in the simmering soup, and cover, and they take about 30-40 min. to cook through (longer than it says on the box). Make the little balls about the sizes of a big grape. They expand *a lot* when they cook. They don't have to be perfectly round. The dough is pretty sticky to work with.

After the matzoh balls are cooked, if you're not serving it right away, turn off the fire, and just leave it on the stove covered. Heat it up before you serve or refrigerate it and heat up the next day. If you want to be a big shot, then chop up a little fresh flat leaf parsley and sprinkle a pinch of it over the soup when you serve it.

Additional info. If you don't know, matzoh balls are like dumplings made from matzoh meal, which is just unleavened bread (flour and water) that's crushed up.

The soup will be thicker the 2nd day (if there's any left). For thicker soup just boil a bit more rice in it. At least 30 mins boiling if you add rice.

Carrots--I usually buy the little packages of peeled and washed little carrots. I use about half of the package and feed some carrots to the dogs, who love them. Good for them and good for their teeth.

Celery--the greener the celery is, the tastier it is. Also, always include some of the leaves when you're chopping it up. Most of the flavor is in the leaves.

I could give a much longer more complicated recipe for chicken soup which involves all kinds of chicken parts, straining it, clarifying it, skimming the fat off etc. etc. etc. and takes 2-3 days to make, but frankly this soup is just as good and a *lot* faster. My grandmother, may she rest in peace, said to use the Manischewitz matzoh ball mix because it was just as good as from scratch.

Manischewitz is pronounced Man-i-shev-itz with the accent on the "shev". You should be able to find it in any large grocery store in or near a big city. The brand has been around for over 100 years. I used to buy it in Calgary, but I can't find it here in the Comox Valley.

The soup freezes well, but the matzoh balls don't freeze well, so eat them up first if you want to freeze the soup. Most people who try this say it's the best chicken soup they've ever tasted. You don't have to tell them you added a little soup mix to help. That soup mix was designed for 2 quarts of water, not 5, so it's just helping the flavor, that's all. And my Nana said it was okay to do that. :thumb: And one more thing. The house smells great when you're cooking this.....:D
 
I know only a little bit about Kosher cooking because we have a friend we see occasionally that tries very hard to keep Kosher even when we are all camping out at an event. So I was reading your recipe, which looks great by the way, and was hoping you could tell me what makes it *not* Kosher so I can better understand the rules because there is nothing that popped out at me that said "yup that right there is what does it"
 
I know only a little bit about Kosher cooking because we have a friend we see occasionally that tries very hard to keep Kosher even when we are all camping out at an event. So I was reading your recipe, which looks great by the way, and was hoping you could tell me what makes it *not* Kosher so I can better understand the rules because there is nothing that popped out at me that said "yup that right there is what does it"

Allen could help here.
As I understand it 'kosher' means the animal was killed under certain clean conditions and certified as such by a Rabbi who is present.
For end result reasons, there is almost nothing that can beat Jewish cooking for fullness of flavor and deliciousness.
 
Allen could help here.
As I understand it 'kosher' means the animal was killed under certain clean conditions and certified as such by a Rabbi who is present.
For end result reasons, there is almost nothing that can beat Jewish cooking for fullness of flavor and deliciousness.

Frank, you're right. I use chicken that I buy at the grocery. For it to be Kosher the chicken would have to be Kosher (or come from a Kosher butcher.) There are lots of rules regarding what is Kosher, but the chicken being Kosher is the only thing that applies here. In fact, the Manischewitz soup and matzoh ball mix *is* Kosher.
 
Looks good Cynthia.
But, I have to ask. Why do you not put the entire chicken, bones and all in the pot to add richness to stock?

Frank, only because this is faster. If I was making the old-fashioned traditional soup, yes, I would use the whole chicken in pieces, skin, bones, etc. You're right. Except if I do that, then the stock tends to be a) cloudy and b) when the chicken cooks and breaks down, there are all kinds of other nasty bits that I have to fish out of there and c) you need the extra step of removing the fat after it cools.

So if I use the entire chicken, I have to cook the chicken first, then strain it, then clarify it, then remove the fat, then heat it up a second time with all the vegetables....it's a 2-day job, minimum. This soup is a 2 hour job.
 
Frank, only because this is faster. If I was making the old-fashioned traditional soup, yes, I would use the whole chicken in pieces, skin, bones, etc. You're right. Except if I do that, then the stock tends to be a) cloudy and b) when the chicken cooks and breaks down, there are all kinds of other nasty bits that I have to fish out of there and c) you need the extra step of removing the fat after it cools.

So if I use the entire chicken, I have to cook the chicken first, then strain it, then clarify it, then remove the fat, then heat it up a second time with all the vegetables....it's a 2-day job, minimum. This soup is a 2 hour job.

That's alright. You do it. Just call me when it's ready. :rolleyes:
 
I know only a little bit about Kosher cooking because we have a friend we see occasionally that tries very hard to keep Kosher even when we are all camping out at an event. So I was reading your recipe, which looks great by the way, and was hoping you could tell me what makes it *not* Kosher so I can better understand the rules because there is nothing that popped out at me that said "yup that right there is what does it"

Like Frank said, in this case, it's only because the chicken isn't Kosher. (It didn't come from a Kosher butcher.)
 
I hope you dont mean ask this allen, cause Ive never kept a kosher home.

The meat isnt kosher.

The pot used to prepare the chicken isnt kosher.

The utensils used to prepare the food isnt kosher.

both pots and pans and cooking utensils could not be used to prepare any non kosher products.

You cant mix meat and dairy pots and pans, or mix meat and dairy utensils.

cynthia also uses the same pots and pans (Im pretty sure) year round, and on passover you need to have a completely different set of dishes and utensils.

Since IM sure Cynthia uses her soup pot for more than just meat, its not a kosher pot. so even if the chicken was kosher, it wouldnt mean much Im thinking.

Youd have to ask someone kosher to find out all the reasons.
 
Last edited:
I hope you dont mean ask this allen, cause Ive never kept a kosher home.

The meat isnt kosher.

The pot used to prepare the chicken isnt kosher.

The utensils used to prepare the food isnt kosher.

both pots and pans and cooking utensils could not be used to prepare any non kosher products.

You cant mix meat and dairy pots and pans, or mix meat and dairy utensils.

cynthia also uses the same pots and pans (Im pretty sure) year round, and on passover you need to have a completely different set of dishes and utensils.

Since IM sure Cynthia uses her soup pot for more than just meat, its not a kosher pot. so even if the chicken was kosher, it wouldnt mean much Im thinking.

Youd have to ask someone kosher to find out all the reasons.

Allen is right. I was just talking about the soup itself.
 
Top